I'm new to TM Forum and evaluate how to revamp in house SOM application based on TMF 633/TMF 641/ TMF 638. I read TMF633 Service catalog ...
Skiptomaincontent(PressEnter).
LogIn
Skipauxiliarynavigation(PressEnter).
tmforum.orgHelp/FAQsContactUsCodeofConduct
Skipmainnavigation(PressEnter).
Togglenavigation
SearchOptions
HomeCommunitiesAllCommunitiesMyCommunitiesDirectoryEventsUpcomingEventsBrowseDiscussionPostsLibraryEntries
CommunitiesCommunityHomeDiscussionTopicThread
OpenAPIs
ViewOnly
CommunityHome
Discussion
5.7K
Library
41
Events
0
Members
48.4K
Backtodiscussions
Expandall|
Collapseall
sortbymostrecent
sortbythread
UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)
waichowJul21,202008:08Hi,
I'mnewtoTMForumandevaluatehowtorevampinhouseSOMapplicationbasedonTMF633/TM...JonathanGoldbergJul21,202008:20HiWaiWelcome,hopeyouwillfindyourinteractionwiththeTMForumproductiveforyourselfand...waichowJul23,202004:15HiJonathan,Thanksforyourclarification.IfIneedtocreatewith...JonathanGoldbergJul23,202006:21HiWaiTheservicecatalogdefinitionreflectstheservice,nottheoperationsthatyoucarryout...VanceShipleyJul27,202001:36Whileit'struethat"theOpenAPImodeldoesnotdistinguishbetweenCFSandRFS"explicitlyit...waichowJul27,202003:54HiJonathan,Mymainpurposeistodefinespecification(CFS)fornorthbound/COM.Then,ourmi...JonathanGoldbergJul27,202007:10TMF633isacatalogAPI,representingthefunctionalityofdefiningservicesandtheircapabili...WingSinJul27,202007:33HiJonathan,Thanksforyourcomments,Ihaveupdatedthespecaccordingly. However,Iwant...JonathanGoldbergJul28,202011:41HiWingIthinkyouraisedsomethingsimilarinanotherpost,regardingmappingbetweenaninte...WingSinAug25,202007:57Hi Jonathan,Thanksforyourcomments,Ihaveupdatedthespec.Wouldyoupleaseadviseifw...JonathanGoldbergAug26,202001:46HiWingTomynon-practicedeyeyourexamplelooksOK.Ialreadystatedmyrecommendation,whi...
1.
UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)
0
Like
TMForumMember
waichow
PostedJul21,202008:08
Reply
ReplyPrivately
OptionsDropdown
Hi,
I'mnewtoTMForumandevaluatehowtorevampinhouseSOMapplicationbasedonTMF633/TMF641/TMF638.
IreadTMF633ServicecatalogmanagementAPIRESTspecification(release18.5.0/pp21,27-29)butIhavenogluehowtodeclare/representsimple(keyvalue)servicespecification.
Forsimple/standaloneservicespecwithoutanyservicedependency,shouldIdeclareeverythinginServiceSpecification/ServiceSpecCharacteristic/ServiceSpecCharacteristicValue?Regards------------------------------WaiChowPCCWSolutionsLimited------------------------------
2.
RE:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)
1
Like
TMForumMember
JonathanGoldberg
PostedJul21,202008:20
Reply
ReplyPrivately
OptionsDropdown
HiWaiWelcome,hopeyouwillfindyourinteractionwiththeTMForumproductiveforyourselfandyourcompany.AllthepublishedOpenAPIuserguides(weusedtocallthemspecifications)includeexamplesofJSONresourcesandpayloads.AstheOpenAPIteamcontinuetoworkonAPIdefinitions,wetrytorefineandupdatetheexamplessothattheywillreflectrealbusinessscenarios,asfaraspossible.Indeedthesimplestwaytodefineaserviceinthecatalogistousecompletelydynamicdefinitions,withspecifications,specificationcharacteristics,andvalues.Anexamplebelow(admittedlyfromResourceCatalog,buttheideaisverysimilarforServiceCatalog)foraverysimplespecforastoragewithonecharacteristicforthemaximumstorage,usingvaluestorepresentthelistofallowedvalues.Hopeithelps.
{
"name":"VirtualStorageMedium",
"description":"Thisresourcespecificationdefinesthevirtualstoragemedium",
"@type":"LogicalResourceSpecification",
"@baseType":"ResourceSpecification",
"resourceSpecCharacteristic":[
{
"name":"MaximumAllowedStorage",
"description":"Thestoragelimitinthevirtualstoragemedium,",
"valueType":"integer",
"configurable":true,
"minCardinality":1,
"maxCardinality":1,
"isUnique":true,
"resourceSpecCharacteristicValue":[
{
"valueType":"integer",
"value":1024000
},
{
"valueType":"integer",
"value":2048000
}
]
}
]
}------------------------------JonathanGoldbergAmdocsManagementLimitedAnyopinionsandstatementsmadebymeonthisforumarepurelypersonal,anddonotnecessarilyreflectthepositionoftheTMForumormyemployer.------------------------------
OriginalMessage
OriginalMessage:Sent:Jul21,202002:48From:waichowSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)Hi,I'mnewtoTMForumandevaluatehowtorevampinhouseSOMapplicationbasedonTMF633/TMF641/TMF638.IreadTMF633ServicecatalogmanagementAPIRESTspecification(release18.5.0/pp21,27-29)butIhavenogluehowtodeclare/representsimple(keyvalue)servicespecification.Forsimple/standaloneservicespecwithoutanyservicedependency,shouldIdeclareeverythinginServiceSpecification/ServiceSpecCharacteristic/ServiceSpecCharacteristicValue?Regards------------------------------WaiChowPCCWSolutionsLimited------------------------------
3.
RE:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)
0
Like
TMForumMember
waichow
PostedJul23,202004:15
Reply
ReplyPrivately
OptionsDropdown
HiJonathan,Thanksforyourclarification.IfIneedtocreatewiththreeoperations/actions,shouldIcreate
1servicecatalog
3servicecatalog(,,)?
eg/
{
"name": "ADDVMS",
"description": "Add Voice Mail Service Specification",
"isBundle": true,
"lastUpdate": "2020-07-22T02:47:10.141Z",
"lifecycleStatus": "Active",
"version": "0.1",
"serviceSpecCharacteristic": [
{
"configurable": true,
"name": "MSISDN",
"description": "Mobile Number",
"extensible": true,
"isUnique": true,
"maxCardinality": 1,
"minCardinality": 1,
"valueType": "string"
},
{
"configurable": true,
"name": "IMSI",
"description": "IMSINumber",
"extensible": true,
"isUnique": true,
"maxCardinality": 1,
"minCardinality": 1,
"valueType": "string"
},
{
"configurable": true,
"name": "BRANDCODE",
"description": "Brand (mapping)",
"extensible": true,
"isUnique": true,
"maxCardinality": 1,
"minCardinality": 1,
"valueType": "string",
"serviceSpecCharacteristicValue": [
{
"isDefault": true,
"valueType": "String"
"value": "0"
},
{
"isDefault": false,
"valueType": "String"
"value": "1"
}
]
},
{
"configurable": true,
"name": "VMSSERVICECLASS",
"description": "Mail Box Type",
"extensible": true,
"isUnique": true,
"maxCardinality": 1,
"minCardinality": 1,
"regex": "",
"valueType": "string",
"serviceSpecCharacteristicValue": [
{
"isDefault": true,
"valueType": "String"
"value": "3"
},
{
"isDefault": false,
"valueType": "String"
"value": "5"
}
]
},
{
"configurable": true,
"name": "VMSLANG",
"description": "Mail Box Language (mapping)",
"extensible": true,
"isUnique": true,
"maxCardinality": 1,
"minCardinality": 1,
"regex": "",
"valueType": "string",
"serviceSpecCharacteristicValue": [
{
"isDefault": false,
"valueType": "String"
"value": "1"
},
{
"isDefault": true,
"valueType": "String"
"value": "2"
},
{
"isDefault": false,
"valueType": "String"
"value": "3"
}
]
}
],
"@type": "CustomerFacingServiceSpecification"
}
Thanks------------------------------waichowPCCWSolutionsLimited------------------------------
OriginalMessage
OriginalMessage:Sent:Jul21,202008:19From:JonathanGoldbergSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)HiWaiWelcome,hopeyouwillfindyourinteractionwiththeTMForumproductiveforyourselfandyourcompany.AllthepublishedOpenAPIuserguides(weusedtocallthemspecifications)includeexamplesofJSONresourcesandpayloads.AstheOpenAPIteamcontinuetoworkonAPIdefinitions,wetrytorefineandupdatetheexamplessothattheywillreflectrealbusinessscenarios,asfaraspossible.Indeedthesimplestwaytodefineaserviceinthecatalogistousecompletelydynamicdefinitions,withspecifications,specificationcharacteristics,andvalues.Anexamplebelow(admittedlyfromResourceCatalog,buttheideaisverysimilarforServiceCatalog)foraverysimplespecforastoragewithonecharacteristicforthemaximumstorage,usingvaluestorepresentthelistofallowedvalues.Hopeithelps.{ "name":"VirtualStorageMedium", "description":"Thisresourcespecificationdefinesthevirtualstoragemedium", "@type":"LogicalResourceSpecification", "@baseType":"ResourceSpecification", "resourceSpecCharacteristic":[ { "name":"MaximumAllowedStorage", "description":"Thestoragelimitinthevirtualstoragemedium,", "valueType":"integer", "configurable":true, "minCardinality":1, "maxCardinality":1, "isUnique":true, "resourceSpecCharacteristicValue":[ { "valueType":"integer", "value":1024000 }, { "valueType":"integer", "value":2048000 } ] } ]}------------------------------JonathanGoldbergAmdocsManagementLimitedAnyopinionsandstatementsmadebymeonthisforumarepurelypersonal,anddonotnecessarilyreflectthepositionoftheTMForumormyemployer.OriginalMessage:Sent:Jul21,202002:48From:waichowSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)Hi,I'mnewtoTMForumandevaluatehowtorevampinhouseSOMapplicationbasedonTMF633/TMF641/TMF638.IreadTMF633ServicecatalogmanagementAPIRESTspecification(release18.5.0/pp21,27-29)butIhavenogluehowtodeclare/representsimple(keyvalue)servicespecification.Forsimple/standaloneservicespecwithoutanyservicedependency,shouldIdeclareeverythinginServiceSpecification/ServiceSpecCharacteristic/ServiceSpecCharacteristicValue?Regards------------------------------WaiChowPCCWSolutionsLimited------------------------------
4.
RE:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)
0
Like
TMForumMember
JonathanGoldberg
PostedJul23,202006:21
Reply
ReplyPrivately
OptionsDropdown
HiWaiTheservicecatalogdefinitionreflectstheservice,nottheoperationsthatyoucarryoutontheservice.YoushouldcreateasingleVoiceMailservicespecificationinthecatalog.Toadd,change,orremovevoice-mail,youwouldpresumablyneedtoprocessaserviceorderTMF641-orperhapsifyoucanworkdirectlyagainstthenetworkyoucoulduseserviceactivationandconfigurationTMF640.Specificcommentsonyourproposedmodel:
TheOpenAPImodeldoesnotdistinguishbetweenCFSandRFS-ifyouwanttomakethatdistinctionthat'sfine,butthenyouneedtoincludea@baseTypethatcontainsServiceSpecificationanda@schemaLocationthatdefinesCFSextensiontoServiceSpec.
Ithinkitwouldbebettertohavetruevaluesinyourcharacteristicexamples,sothatsomeonewholooksatthespec(andtheinstantiationintheinventory)canunderstandthesemanticmeaning.Valuessuchas"3"and"5"forserviceclass,or"1"and"2"fornationallanguage,arenotnecessarilyhelpful.
IfyousetisBundletotrue,theexpectationisthattheservicespechassub-structure,andIwouldexpecttoseeareferencetoacontainedservicespec.
Hopeithelps------------------------------JonathanGoldbergAmdocsManagementLimitedAnyopinionsandstatementsmadebymeonthisforumarepurelypersonal,anddonotnecessarilyreflectthepositionoftheTMForumormyemployer.------------------------------
OriginalMessage
OriginalMessage:Sent:Jul23,202004:15From:waichowSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)HiJonathan,Thanksforyourclarification.IfIneedtocreatewiththreeoperations/actions,shouldIcreate1servicecatalog3servicecatalog(,,)?eg/{ "name": "ADDVMS", "description": "Add Voice Mail Service Specification", "isBundle": true, "lastUpdate": "2020-07-22T02:47:10.141Z", "lifecycleStatus": "Active", "version": "0.1", "serviceSpecCharacteristic": [ { "configurable": true, "name": "MSISDN", "description": "Mobile Number", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "valueType": "string" }, { "configurable": true, "name": "IMSI", "description": "IMSINumber", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "valueType": "string" }, { "configurable": true, "name": "BRANDCODE", "description": "Brand (mapping)", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "valueType": "string", "serviceSpecCharacteristicValue": [ { "isDefault": true, "valueType": "String" "value": "0" }, { "isDefault": false, "valueType": "String" "value": "1" } ] }, { "configurable": true, "name": "VMSSERVICECLASS", "description": "Mail Box Type", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "regex": "", "valueType": "string", "serviceSpecCharacteristicValue": [ { "isDefault": true, "valueType": "String" "value": "3" }, { "isDefault": false, "valueType": "String" "value": "5" } ] }, { "configurable": true, "name": "VMSLANG", "description": "Mail Box Language (mapping)", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "regex": "", "valueType": "string", "serviceSpecCharacteristicValue": [ { "isDefault": false, "valueType": "String" "value": "1" }, { "isDefault": true, "valueType": "String" "value": "2" }, { "isDefault": false, "valueType": "String" "value": "3" } ] } ], "@type": "CustomerFacingServiceSpecification"}Thanks------------------------------waichowPCCWSolutionsLimitedOriginalMessage:Sent:Jul21,202008:19From:JonathanGoldbergSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)HiWaiWelcome,hopeyouwillfindyourinteractionwiththeTMForumproductiveforyourselfandyourcompany.AllthepublishedOpenAPIuserguides(weusedtocallthemspecifications)includeexamplesofJSONresourcesandpayloads.AstheOpenAPIteamcontinuetoworkonAPIdefinitions,wetrytorefineandupdatetheexamplessothattheywillreflectrealbusinessscenarios,asfaraspossible.Indeedthesimplestwaytodefineaserviceinthecatalogistousecompletelydynamicdefinitions,withspecifications,specificationcharacteristics,andvalues.Anexamplebelow(admittedlyfromResourceCatalog,buttheideaisverysimilarforServiceCatalog)foraverysimplespecforastoragewithonecharacteristicforthemaximumstorage,usingvaluestorepresentthelistofallowedvalues.Hopeithelps.{ "name":"VirtualStorageMedium", "description":"Thisresourcespecificationdefinesthevirtualstoragemedium", "@type":"LogicalResourceSpecification", "@baseType":"ResourceSpecification", "resourceSpecCharacteristic":[ { "name":"MaximumAllowedStorage", "description":"Thestoragelimitinthevirtualstoragemedium,", "valueType":"integer", "configurable":true, "minCardinality":1, "maxCardinality":1, "isUnique":true, "resourceSpecCharacteristicValue":[ { "valueType":"integer", "value":1024000 }, { "valueType":"integer", "value":2048000 } ] } ]}------------------------------JonathanGoldbergAmdocsManagementLimitedAnyopinionsandstatementsmadebymeonthisforumarepurelypersonal,anddonotnecessarilyreflectthepositionoftheTMForumormyemployer.OriginalMessage:Sent:Jul21,202002:48From:waichowSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)Hi,I'mnewtoTMForumandevaluatehowtorevampinhouseSOMapplicationbasedonTMF633/TMF641/TMF638.IreadTMF633ServicecatalogmanagementAPIRESTspecification(release18.5.0/pp21,27-29)butIhavenogluehowtodeclare/representsimple(keyvalue)servicespecification.Forsimple/standaloneservicespecwithoutanyservicedependency,shouldIdeclareeverythinginServiceSpecification/ServiceSpecCharacteristic/ServiceSpecCharacteristicValue?Regards------------------------------WaiChowPCCWSolutionsLimited------------------------------
5.
RE:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)
0
Like
TMForumMember
VanceShipley
PostedJul27,202001:36
Reply
ReplyPrivately
OptionsDropdown
Whileit'struethat"theOpenAPImodeldoesnotdistinguishbetweenCFSandRFS"explicitlyitdoessoimplicitlybytheinclusionofresourceSpecificationinanRFS.------------------------------VanceShipleySigScale------------------------------
OriginalMessage
OriginalMessage:Sent:Jul23,202006:21From:JonathanGoldbergSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)HiWaiTheservicecatalogdefinitionreflectstheservice,nottheoperationsthatyoucarryoutontheservice.YoushouldcreateasingleVoiceMailservicespecificationinthecatalog.Toadd,change,orremovevoice-mail,youwouldpresumablyneedtoprocessaserviceorderTMF641-orperhapsifyoucanworkdirectlyagainstthenetworkyoucoulduseserviceactivationandconfigurationTMF640.Specificcommentsonyourproposedmodel:TheOpenAPImodeldoesnotdistinguishbetweenCFSandRFS-ifyouwanttomakethatdistinctionthat'sfine,butthenyouneedtoincludea@baseTypethatcontainsServiceSpecificationanda@schemaLocationthatdefinesCFSextensiontoServiceSpec.Ithinkitwouldbebettertohavetruevaluesinyourcharacteristicexamples,sothatsomeonewholooksatthespec(andtheinstantiationintheinventory)canunderstandthesemanticmeaning.Valuessuchas"3"and"5"forserviceclass,or"1"and"2"fornationallanguage,arenotnecessarilyhelpful.IfyousetisBundletotrue,theexpectationisthattheservicespechassub-structure,andIwouldexpecttoseeareferencetoacontainedservicespec.Hopeithelps------------------------------JonathanGoldbergAmdocsManagementLimitedAnyopinionsandstatementsmadebymeonthisforumarepurelypersonal,anddonotnecessarilyreflectthepositionoftheTMForumormyemployer.OriginalMessage:Sent:Jul23,202004:15From:waichowSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)HiJonathan,Thanksforyourclarification.IfIneedtocreatewiththreeoperations/actions,shouldIcreate1servicecatalog3servicecatalog(,,)?eg/{ "name": "ADDVMS", "description": "Add Voice Mail Service Specification", "isBundle": true, "lastUpdate": "2020-07-22T02:47:10.141Z", "lifecycleStatus": "Active", "version": "0.1", "serviceSpecCharacteristic": [ { "configurable": true, "name": "MSISDN", "description": "Mobile Number", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "valueType": "string" }, { "configurable": true, "name": "IMSI", "description": "IMSINumber", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "valueType": "string" }, { "configurable": true, "name": "BRANDCODE", "description": "Brand (mapping)", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "valueType": "string", "serviceSpecCharacteristicValue": [ { "isDefault": true, "valueType": "String" "value": "0" }, { "isDefault": false, "valueType": "String" "value": "1" } ] }, { "configurable": true, "name": "VMSSERVICECLASS", "description": "Mail Box Type", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "regex": "", "valueType": "string", "serviceSpecCharacteristicValue": [ { "isDefault": true, "valueType": "String" "value": "3" }, { "isDefault": false, "valueType": "String" "value": "5" } ] }, { "configurable": true, "name": "VMSLANG", "description": "Mail Box Language (mapping)", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "regex": "", "valueType": "string", "serviceSpecCharacteristicValue": [ { "isDefault": false, "valueType": "String" "value": "1" }, { "isDefault": true, "valueType": "String" "value": "2" }, { "isDefault": false, "valueType": "String" "value": "3" } ] } ], "@type": "CustomerFacingServiceSpecification"}Thanks------------------------------waichowPCCWSolutionsLimitedOriginalMessage:Sent:Jul21,202008:19From:JonathanGoldbergSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)HiWaiWelcome,hopeyouwillfindyourinteractionwiththeTMForumproductiveforyourselfandyourcompany.AllthepublishedOpenAPIuserguides(weusedtocallthemspecifications)includeexamplesofJSONresourcesandpayloads.AstheOpenAPIteamcontinuetoworkonAPIdefinitions,wetrytorefineandupdatetheexamplessothattheywillreflectrealbusinessscenarios,asfaraspossible.Indeedthesimplestwaytodefineaserviceinthecatalogistousecompletelydynamicdefinitions,withspecifications,specificationcharacteristics,andvalues.Anexamplebelow(admittedlyfromResourceCatalog,buttheideaisverysimilarforServiceCatalog)foraverysimplespecforastoragewithonecharacteristicforthemaximumstorage,usingvaluestorepresentthelistofallowedvalues.Hopeithelps.{ "name":"VirtualStorageMedium", "description":"Thisresourcespecificationdefinesthevirtualstoragemedium", "@type":"LogicalResourceSpecification", "@baseType":"ResourceSpecification", "resourceSpecCharacteristic":[ { "name":"MaximumAllowedStorage", "description":"Thestoragelimitinthevirtualstoragemedium,", "valueType":"integer", "configurable":true, "minCardinality":1, "maxCardinality":1, "isUnique":true, "resourceSpecCharacteristicValue":[ { "valueType":"integer", "value":1024000 }, { "valueType":"integer", "value":2048000 } ] } ]}------------------------------JonathanGoldbergAmdocsManagementLimitedAnyopinionsandstatementsmadebymeonthisforumarepurelypersonal,anddonotnecessarilyreflectthepositionoftheTMForumormyemployer.OriginalMessage:Sent:Jul21,202002:48From:waichowSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)Hi,I'mnewtoTMForumandevaluatehowtorevampinhouseSOMapplicationbasedonTMF633/TMF641/TMF638.IreadTMF633ServicecatalogmanagementAPIRESTspecification(release18.5.0/pp21,27-29)butIhavenogluehowtodeclare/representsimple(keyvalue)servicespecification.Forsimple/standaloneservicespecwithoutanyservicedependency,shouldIdeclareeverythinginServiceSpecification/ServiceSpecCharacteristic/ServiceSpecCharacteristicValue?Regards------------------------------WaiChowPCCWSolutionsLimited------------------------------
6.
RE:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)
0
Like
TMForumMember
waichow
PostedJul27,202003:54
Reply
ReplyPrivately
OptionsDropdown
HiJonathan,Mymainpurposeistodefinespecification(CFS)fornorthbound/COM.Then,ourmiddleware(SOM)shouldtranslate/decomposeTMF641orderandtheninvokeRFSservicelogic. Idon'twantnorthbound/COMtoinvoketheRFS/TMF640directly.SoIwillperformthese2activities.
Defineservicecatalog(TMF633)withoutanyoperationcarryoutontheservice.
Defineorderspec(TMF640)withoperationscarryoutontheservice
AmIontherighttrack?SeemsTMF633itselfwithoutanyoperationcarryoutontheservicedoesnothavetoomuchvalueatall,doImisunderstandtherationalebehindTMF633?Thanks------------------------------waichowPCCWSolutionsLimited------------------------------
OriginalMessage
OriginalMessage:Sent:Jul23,202006:21From:JonathanGoldbergSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)HiWaiTheservicecatalogdefinitionreflectstheservice,nottheoperationsthatyoucarryoutontheservice.YoushouldcreateasingleVoiceMailservicespecificationinthecatalog.Toadd,change,orremovevoice-mail,youwouldpresumablyneedtoprocessaserviceorderTMF641-orperhapsifyoucanworkdirectlyagainstthenetworkyoucoulduseserviceactivationandconfigurationTMF640.Specificcommentsonyourproposedmodel:TheOpenAPImodeldoesnotdistinguishbetweenCFSandRFS-ifyouwanttomakethatdistinctionthat'sfine,butthenyouneedtoincludea@baseTypethatcontainsServiceSpecificationanda@schemaLocationthatdefinesCFSextensiontoServiceSpec.Ithinkitwouldbebettertohavetruevaluesinyourcharacteristicexamples,sothatsomeonewholooksatthespec(andtheinstantiationintheinventory)canunderstandthesemanticmeaning.Valuessuchas"3"and"5"forserviceclass,or"1"and"2"fornationallanguage,arenotnecessarilyhelpful.IfyousetisBundletotrue,theexpectationisthattheservicespechassub-structure,andIwouldexpecttoseeareferencetoacontainedservicespec.Hopeithelps------------------------------JonathanGoldbergAmdocsManagementLimitedAnyopinionsandstatementsmadebymeonthisforumarepurelypersonal,anddonotnecessarilyreflectthepositionoftheTMForumormyemployer.OriginalMessage:Sent:Jul23,202004:15From:waichowSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)HiJonathan,Thanksforyourclarification.IfIneedtocreatewiththreeoperations/actions,shouldIcreate1servicecatalog3servicecatalog(,,)?eg/{ "name": "ADDVMS", "description": "Add Voice Mail Service Specification", "isBundle": true, "lastUpdate": "2020-07-22T02:47:10.141Z", "lifecycleStatus": "Active", "version": "0.1", "serviceSpecCharacteristic": [ { "configurable": true, "name": "MSISDN", "description": "Mobile Number", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "valueType": "string" }, { "configurable": true, "name": "IMSI", "description": "IMSINumber", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "valueType": "string" }, { "configurable": true, "name": "BRANDCODE", "description": "Brand (mapping)", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "valueType": "string", "serviceSpecCharacteristicValue": [ { "isDefault": true, "valueType": "String" "value": "0" }, { "isDefault": false, "valueType": "String" "value": "1" } ] }, { "configurable": true, "name": "VMSSERVICECLASS", "description": "Mail Box Type", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "regex": "", "valueType": "string", "serviceSpecCharacteristicValue": [ { "isDefault": true, "valueType": "String" "value": "3" }, { "isDefault": false, "valueType": "String" "value": "5" } ] }, { "configurable": true, "name": "VMSLANG", "description": "Mail Box Language (mapping)", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "regex": "", "valueType": "string", "serviceSpecCharacteristicValue": [ { "isDefault": false, "valueType": "String" "value": "1" }, { "isDefault": true, "valueType": "String" "value": "2" }, { "isDefault": false, "valueType": "String" "value": "3" } ] } ], "@type": "CustomerFacingServiceSpecification"}Thanks------------------------------waichowPCCWSolutionsLimitedOriginalMessage:Sent:Jul21,202008:19From:JonathanGoldbergSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)HiWaiWelcome,hopeyouwillfindyourinteractionwiththeTMForumproductiveforyourselfandyourcompany.AllthepublishedOpenAPIuserguides(weusedtocallthemspecifications)includeexamplesofJSONresourcesandpayloads.AstheOpenAPIteamcontinuetoworkonAPIdefinitions,wetrytorefineandupdatetheexamplessothattheywillreflectrealbusinessscenarios,asfaraspossible.Indeedthesimplestwaytodefineaserviceinthecatalogistousecompletelydynamicdefinitions,withspecifications,specificationcharacteristics,andvalues.Anexamplebelow(admittedlyfromResourceCatalog,buttheideaisverysimilarforServiceCatalog)foraverysimplespecforastoragewithonecharacteristicforthemaximumstorage,usingvaluestorepresentthelistofallowedvalues.Hopeithelps.{ "name":"VirtualStorageMedium", "description":"Thisresourcespecificationdefinesthevirtualstoragemedium", "@type":"LogicalResourceSpecification", "@baseType":"ResourceSpecification", "resourceSpecCharacteristic":[ { "name":"MaximumAllowedStorage", "description":"Thestoragelimitinthevirtualstoragemedium,", "valueType":"integer", "configurable":true, "minCardinality":1, "maxCardinality":1, "isUnique":true, "resourceSpecCharacteristicValue":[ { "valueType":"integer", "value":1024000 }, { "valueType":"integer", "value":2048000 } ] } ]}------------------------------JonathanGoldbergAmdocsManagementLimitedAnyopinionsandstatementsmadebymeonthisforumarepurelypersonal,anddonotnecessarilyreflectthepositionoftheTMForumormyemployer.OriginalMessage:Sent:Jul21,202002:48From:waichowSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)Hi,I'mnewtoTMForumandevaluatehowtorevampinhouseSOMapplicationbasedonTMF633/TMF641/TMF638.IreadTMF633ServicecatalogmanagementAPIRESTspecification(release18.5.0/pp21,27-29)butIhavenogluehowtodeclare/representsimple(keyvalue)servicespecification.Forsimple/standaloneservicespecwithoutanyservicedependency,shouldIdeclareeverythinginServiceSpecification/ServiceSpecCharacteristic/ServiceSpecCharacteristicValue?Regards------------------------------WaiChowPCCWSolutionsLimited------------------------------
7.
RE:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)
0
Like
TMForumMember
JonathanGoldberg
PostedJul27,202007:10
Reply
ReplyPrivately
OptionsDropdown
TMF633isacatalogAPI,representingthefunctionalityofdefiningservicesandtheircapabilities.TMF640isoneofafamilyofinstanceAPIsintheservicedomain,representingfunctionalityofactingonaspecificservice(inthiscaseactivatingandconfiguringtheserviceinthenetwork).SoTMF640isnottheplacetoexposetheallowedactions.Subjecttocorrectionbydomainexpertssuchas@VanceShipleyand@KamalMaghsoudlou,itseemstomethatthereisatacitassumptionthatthereisafixedandclosedlistofactionsyoucantakeonaservice,adding,modifying,suspending,resuming,andterminating.Perhapsyouwouldliketoseeamoreexplicitlistofactionsdefinedatcataloglevel,sincesomeserviceswouldnotallowsuspendorresume,othersmightnotallowmodify,etc.ThisconceptismissingfromtheOpenAPIcatalogAPIs(Product,Service,Resource);itispresentintheInformationFramework(SID)forProductintheProductActionABE,butthereisnoSIDequivalentforServiceactions.So inanimplementationofTMF640APIyoumightwellrejectarequestto(forexample)suspendaservice,basedonyourinternalknowledgeoftheservicedefinition,eventhoughthisisnotcurrentlyrepresentedincatalogAPIs.Hopeithelps------------------------------JonathanGoldbergAmdocsManagementLimitedAnyopinionsandstatementsmadebymeonthisforumarepurelypersonal,anddonotnecessarilyreflectthepositionoftheTMForumormyemployer.------------------------------
OriginalMessage
OriginalMessage:Sent:Jul27,202003:53From:waichowSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)HiJonathan,Mymainpurposeistodefinespecification(CFS)fornorthbound/COM.Then,ourmiddleware(SOM)shouldtranslate/decomposeTMF641orderandtheninvokeRFSservicelogic. Idon'twantnorthbound/COMtoinvoketheRFS/TMF640directly.SoIwillperformthese2activities.Defineservicecatalog(TMF633)withoutanyoperationcarryoutontheservice.Defineorderspec(TMF640)withoperationscarryoutontheserviceAmIontherighttrack?SeemsTMF633itselfwithoutanyoperationcarryoutontheservicedoesnothavetoomuchvalueatall,doImisunderstandtherationalebehindTMF633?Thanks------------------------------waichowPCCWSolutionsLimitedOriginalMessage:Sent:Jul23,202006:21From:JonathanGoldbergSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)HiWaiTheservicecatalogdefinitionreflectstheservice,nottheoperationsthatyoucarryoutontheservice.YoushouldcreateasingleVoiceMailservicespecificationinthecatalog.Toadd,change,orremovevoice-mail,youwouldpresumablyneedtoprocessaserviceorderTMF641-orperhapsifyoucanworkdirectlyagainstthenetworkyoucoulduseserviceactivationandconfigurationTMF640.Specificcommentsonyourproposedmodel:TheOpenAPImodeldoesnotdistinguishbetweenCFSandRFS-ifyouwanttomakethatdistinctionthat'sfine,butthenyouneedtoincludea@baseTypethatcontainsServiceSpecificationanda@schemaLocationthatdefinesCFSextensiontoServiceSpec.Ithinkitwouldbebettertohavetruevaluesinyourcharacteristicexamples,sothatsomeonewholooksatthespec(andtheinstantiationintheinventory)canunderstandthesemanticmeaning.Valuessuchas"3"and"5"forserviceclass,or"1"and"2"fornationallanguage,arenotnecessarilyhelpful.IfyousetisBundletotrue,theexpectationisthattheservicespechassub-structure,andIwouldexpecttoseeareferencetoacontainedservicespec.Hopeithelps------------------------------JonathanGoldbergAmdocsManagementLimitedAnyopinionsandstatementsmadebymeonthisforumarepurelypersonal,anddonotnecessarilyreflectthepositionoftheTMForumormyemployer.OriginalMessage:Sent:Jul23,202004:15From:waichowSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)HiJonathan,Thanksforyourclarification.IfIneedtocreatewiththreeoperations/actions,shouldIcreate1servicecatalog3servicecatalog(,,)?eg/{ "name": "ADDVMS", "description": "Add Voice Mail Service Specification", "isBundle": true, "lastUpdate": "2020-07-22T02:47:10.141Z", "lifecycleStatus": "Active", "version": "0.1", "serviceSpecCharacteristic": [ { "configurable": true, "name": "MSISDN", "description": "Mobile Number", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "valueType": "string" }, { "configurable": true, "name": "IMSI", "description": "IMSINumber", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "valueType": "string" }, { "configurable": true, "name": "BRANDCODE", "description": "Brand (mapping)", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "valueType": "string", "serviceSpecCharacteristicValue": [ { "isDefault": true, "valueType": "String" "value": "0" }, { "isDefault": false, "valueType": "String" "value": "1" } ] }, { "configurable": true, "name": "VMSSERVICECLASS", "description": "Mail Box Type", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "regex": "", "valueType": "string", "serviceSpecCharacteristicValue": [ { "isDefault": true, "valueType": "String" "value": "3" }, { "isDefault": false, "valueType": "String" "value": "5" } ] }, { "configurable": true, "name": "VMSLANG", "description": "Mail Box Language (mapping)", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "regex": "", "valueType": "string", "serviceSpecCharacteristicValue": [ { "isDefault": false, "valueType": "String" "value": "1" }, { "isDefault": true, "valueType": "String" "value": "2" }, { "isDefault": false, "valueType": "String" "value": "3" } ] } ], "@type": "CustomerFacingServiceSpecification"}Thanks------------------------------waichowPCCWSolutionsLimitedOriginalMessage:Sent:Jul21,202008:19From:JonathanGoldbergSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)HiWaiWelcome,hopeyouwillfindyourinteractionwiththeTMForumproductiveforyourselfandyourcompany.AllthepublishedOpenAPIuserguides(weusedtocallthemspecifications)includeexamplesofJSONresourcesandpayloads.AstheOpenAPIteamcontinuetoworkonAPIdefinitions,wetrytorefineandupdatetheexamplessothattheywillreflectrealbusinessscenarios,asfaraspossible.Indeedthesimplestwaytodefineaserviceinthecatalogistousecompletelydynamicdefinitions,withspecifications,specificationcharacteristics,andvalues.Anexamplebelow(admittedlyfromResourceCatalog,buttheideaisverysimilarforServiceCatalog)foraverysimplespecforastoragewithonecharacteristicforthemaximumstorage,usingvaluestorepresentthelistofallowedvalues.Hopeithelps.{ "name":"VirtualStorageMedium", "description":"Thisresourcespecificationdefinesthevirtualstoragemedium", "@type":"LogicalResourceSpecification", "@baseType":"ResourceSpecification", "resourceSpecCharacteristic":[ { "name":"MaximumAllowedStorage", "description":"Thestoragelimitinthevirtualstoragemedium,", "valueType":"integer", "configurable":true, "minCardinality":1, "maxCardinality":1, "isUnique":true, "resourceSpecCharacteristicValue":[ { "valueType":"integer", "value":1024000 }, { "valueType":"integer", "value":2048000 } ] } ]}------------------------------JonathanGoldbergAmdocsManagementLimitedAnyopinionsandstatementsmadebymeonthisforumarepurelypersonal,anddonotnecessarilyreflectthepositionoftheTMForumormyemployer.OriginalMessage:Sent:Jul21,202002:48From:waichowSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)Hi,I'mnewtoTMForumandevaluatehowtorevampinhouseSOMapplicationbasedonTMF633/TMF641/TMF638.IreadTMF633ServicecatalogmanagementAPIRESTspecification(release18.5.0/pp21,27-29)butIhavenogluehowtodeclare/representsimple(keyvalue)servicespecification.Forsimple/standaloneservicespecwithoutanyservicedependency,shouldIdeclareeverythinginServiceSpecification/ServiceSpecCharacteristic/ServiceSpecCharacteristicValue?Regards------------------------------WaiChowPCCWSolutionsLimited------------------------------
8.
RE:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)
0
Like
TMForumMember
WingSin
PostedJul27,202007:33
Reply
ReplyPrivately
OptionsDropdown
HiJonathan,Thanksforyourcomments,Ihaveupdatedthespecaccordingly.However,Iwanttoaskhowcanweincludethesemanticmeaninginthespec?Aswewantthevaluepassasavalueinstead,woulditbefinetoadd"description"tagasfollowing?Oranybetterapproach?
Thanks.
"serviceSpecCharacteristicValue":[
{
"isDefault":true,
"valueType":"String",
"value":"3",
"description":"Normal"
},
{
"isDefault":false,
"valueType":"String",
"value":"5",
"description":"Premium"
}
]
{
"name":"VMS",
"description":"VoiceMailServiceSpecification",
"lastUpdate":"2020-07-22T02:47:10.141Z",
"lifecycleStatus":"Active",
"version":"0.1",
"serviceSpecCharacteristic":[
{
"configurable":true,
"name":"MSISDN",
"description":"MobileNumber",
"extensible":true,
"isUnique":true,
"maxCardinality":1,
"minCardinality":1,
"valueType":"string"
},
{
"configurable":true,
"name":"IMSI",
"description":"MobileSIMNumber",
"extensible":true,
"isUnique":true,
"maxCardinality":1,
"minCardinality":1,
"valueType":"string"
},
{
"configurable":true,
"name":"BRANDCODE",
"description":"Brand",
"extensible":true,
"isUnique":true,
"maxCardinality":1,
"minCardinality":1,
"valueType":"string",
"serviceSpecCharacteristicValue":[
{
"isDefault":true,
"valueType":"String",
"value":"0"
},
{
"isDefault":false,
"valueType":"String",
"value":"1"
}
]
},
{
"configurable":true,
"name":"VMSSERVICECLASS",
"description":"MailBoxType",
"extensible":true,
"isUnique":true,
"maxCardinality":1,
"minCardinality":1,
"regex":"",
"valueType":"string",
"serviceSpecCharacteristicValue":[
{
"isDefault":true,
"valueType":"String",
"value":"3"
},
{
"isDefault":false,
"valueType":"String",
"value":"5"
}
]
},
{
"configurable":true,
"name":"VMSLANG",
"description":"MailBoxLanguage",
"extensible":true,
"isUnique":true,
"maxCardinality":1,
"minCardinality":1,
"regex":"",
"valueType":"string",
"serviceSpecCharacteristicValue":[
{
"isDefault":false,
"valueType":"String",
"value":"1"
},
{
"isDefault":true,
"valueType":"String",
"value":"2"
},
{
"isDefault":false,
"valueType":"String",
"value":"3"
}
]
}
]
}------------------------------WingSinPCCWSolutionsLimited------------------------------
OriginalMessage
OriginalMessage:Sent:Jul23,202006:21From:JonathanGoldbergSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)HiWaiTheservicecatalogdefinitionreflectstheservice,nottheoperationsthatyoucarryoutontheservice.YoushouldcreateasingleVoiceMailservicespecificationinthecatalog.Toadd,change,orremovevoice-mail,youwouldpresumablyneedtoprocessaserviceorderTMF641-orperhapsifyoucanworkdirectlyagainstthenetworkyoucoulduseserviceactivationandconfigurationTMF640.Specificcommentsonyourproposedmodel:TheOpenAPImodeldoesnotdistinguishbetweenCFSandRFS-ifyouwanttomakethatdistinctionthat'sfine,butthenyouneedtoincludea@baseTypethatcontainsServiceSpecificationanda@schemaLocationthatdefinesCFSextensiontoServiceSpec.Ithinkitwouldbebettertohavetruevaluesinyourcharacteristicexamples,sothatsomeonewholooksatthespec(andtheinstantiationintheinventory)canunderstandthesemanticmeaning.Valuessuchas"3"and"5"forserviceclass,or"1"and"2"fornationallanguage,arenotnecessarilyhelpful.IfyousetisBundletotrue,theexpectationisthattheservicespechassub-structure,andIwouldexpecttoseeareferencetoacontainedservicespec.Hopeithelps------------------------------JonathanGoldbergAmdocsManagementLimitedAnyopinionsandstatementsmadebymeonthisforumarepurelypersonal,anddonotnecessarilyreflectthepositionoftheTMForumormyemployer.OriginalMessage:Sent:Jul23,202004:15From:waichowSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)HiJonathan,Thanksforyourclarification.IfIneedtocreatewiththreeoperations/actions,shouldIcreate1servicecatalog3servicecatalog(,,)?eg/{ "name": "ADDVMS", "description": "Add Voice Mail Service Specification", "isBundle": true, "lastUpdate": "2020-07-22T02:47:10.141Z", "lifecycleStatus": "Active", "version": "0.1", "serviceSpecCharacteristic": [ { "configurable": true, "name": "MSISDN", "description": "Mobile Number", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "valueType": "string" }, { "configurable": true, "name": "IMSI", "description": "IMSINumber", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "valueType": "string" }, { "configurable": true, "name": "BRANDCODE", "description": "Brand (mapping)", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "valueType": "string", "serviceSpecCharacteristicValue": [ { "isDefault": true, "valueType": "String" "value": "0" }, { "isDefault": false, "valueType": "String" "value": "1" } ] }, { "configurable": true, "name": "VMSSERVICECLASS", "description": "Mail Box Type", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "regex": "", "valueType": "string", "serviceSpecCharacteristicValue": [ { "isDefault": true, "valueType": "String" "value": "3" }, { "isDefault": false, "valueType": "String" "value": "5" } ] }, { "configurable": true, "name": "VMSLANG", "description": "Mail Box Language (mapping)", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "regex": "", "valueType": "string", "serviceSpecCharacteristicValue": [ { "isDefault": false, "valueType": "String" "value": "1" }, { "isDefault": true, "valueType": "String" "value": "2" }, { "isDefault": false, "valueType": "String" "value": "3" } ] } ], "@type": "CustomerFacingServiceSpecification"}Thanks------------------------------waichowPCCWSolutionsLimitedOriginalMessage:Sent:Jul21,202008:19From:JonathanGoldbergSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)HiWaiWelcome,hopeyouwillfindyourinteractionwiththeTMForumproductiveforyourselfandyourcompany.AllthepublishedOpenAPIuserguides(weusedtocallthemspecifications)includeexamplesofJSONresourcesandpayloads.AstheOpenAPIteamcontinuetoworkonAPIdefinitions,wetrytorefineandupdatetheexamplessothattheywillreflectrealbusinessscenarios,asfaraspossible.Indeedthesimplestwaytodefineaserviceinthecatalogistousecompletelydynamicdefinitions,withspecifications,specificationcharacteristics,andvalues.Anexamplebelow(admittedlyfromResourceCatalog,buttheideaisverysimilarforServiceCatalog)foraverysimplespecforastoragewithonecharacteristicforthemaximumstorage,usingvaluestorepresentthelistofallowedvalues.Hopeithelps.{ "name":"VirtualStorageMedium", "description":"Thisresourcespecificationdefinesthevirtualstoragemedium", "@type":"LogicalResourceSpecification", "@baseType":"ResourceSpecification", "resourceSpecCharacteristic":[ { "name":"MaximumAllowedStorage", "description":"Thestoragelimitinthevirtualstoragemedium,", "valueType":"integer", "configurable":true, "minCardinality":1, "maxCardinality":1, "isUnique":true, "resourceSpecCharacteristicValue":[ { "valueType":"integer", "value":1024000 }, { "valueType":"integer", "value":2048000 } ] } ]}------------------------------JonathanGoldbergAmdocsManagementLimitedAnyopinionsandstatementsmadebymeonthisforumarepurelypersonal,anddonotnecessarilyreflectthepositionoftheTMForumormyemployer.OriginalMessage:Sent:Jul21,202002:48From:waichowSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)Hi,I'mnewtoTMForumandevaluatehowtorevampinhouseSOMapplicationbasedonTMF633/TMF641/TMF638.IreadTMF633ServicecatalogmanagementAPIRESTspecification(release18.5.0/pp21,27-29)butIhavenogluehowtodeclare/representsimple(keyvalue)servicespecification.Forsimple/standaloneservicespecwithoutanyservicedependency,shouldIdeclareeverythinginServiceSpecification/ServiceSpecCharacteristic/ServiceSpecCharacteristicValue?Regards------------------------------WaiChowPCCWSolutionsLimited------------------------------
9.
RE:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)
0
Like
TMForumMember
JonathanGoldberg
PostedJul28,202011:41
Reply
ReplyPrivately
OptionsDropdown
HiWingIthinkyouraisedsomethingsimilarinanotherpost,regardingmappingbetweenaninternal(numeric)characteristicvalueinRFSandanexternal(human-semantic)valueinCFS.AtanyratetheOpenAPIdoesnothaveanydistinction(currently,atanyrate)betweenavalueandsomehuman-readablerepresentationofthatvalue.Thisistrueforcharacteristicsandforvaluesinstrongly-typedenums.IguessthattheideaisthattheOpenAPIdealswithbackendintegration,andisnotconcernedwithpresentationissues.YoucanofcourseextendthemodelandAPIbyaddingattributes,perhaps"displayValue"wouldbeclearerthan"description",ifthatisyourintention.Hopeithelps------------------------------JonathanGoldbergAmdocsManagementLimitedAnyopinionsandstatementsmadebymeonthisforumarepurelypersonal,anddonotnecessarilyreflectthepositionoftheTMForumormyemployer.------------------------------
OriginalMessage
OriginalMessage:Sent:Jul26,202023:30From:WingSinSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)HiJonathan,Thanksforyourcomments,Ihaveupdatedthespecaccordingly.However,Iwanttoaskhowcanweincludethesemanticmeaninginthespec?Aswewantthevaluepassasavalueinstead,woulditbefinetoadd"description"tagasfollowing?Oranybetterapproach?Thanks."serviceSpecCharacteristicValue":[{"isDefault":true,"valueType":"String","value":"3","description":"Normal"},{"isDefault":false,"valueType":"String","value":"5","description":"Premium"}]{"name":"VMS","description":"VoiceMailServiceSpecification","lastUpdate":"2020-07-22T02:47:10.141Z","lifecycleStatus":"Active","version":"0.1","serviceSpecCharacteristic":[{"configurable":true,"name":"MSISDN","description":"MobileNumber","extensible":true,"isUnique":true,"maxCardinality":1,"minCardinality":1,"valueType":"string"},{"configurable":true,"name":"IMSI","description":"MobileSIMNumber","extensible":true,"isUnique":true,"maxCardinality":1,"minCardinality":1,"valueType":"string"},{"configurable":true,"name":"BRANDCODE","description":"Brand","extensible":true,"isUnique":true,"maxCardinality":1,"minCardinality":1,"valueType":"string","serviceSpecCharacteristicValue":[{"isDefault":true, "valueType":"String","value":"0"},{"isDefault":false, "valueType":"String","value":"1"}]},{"configurable":true,"name":"VMSSERVICECLASS","description":"MailBoxType","extensible":true,"isUnique":true,"maxCardinality":1,"minCardinality":1,"regex":"","valueType":"string","serviceSpecCharacteristicValue":[{"isDefault":true, "valueType":"String","value":"3"},{"isDefault":false, "valueType":"String","value":"5"}]},{"configurable":true,"name":"VMSLANG","description":"MailBoxLanguage","extensible":true,"isUnique":true,"maxCardinality":1,"minCardinality":1,"regex":"","valueType":"string","serviceSpecCharacteristicValue":[{"isDefault":false, "valueType":"String","value":"1"},{"isDefault":true, "valueType":"String","value":"2"},{"isDefault":false, "valueType":"String","value":"3"}]}]}------------------------------WingSinPCCWSolutionsLimitedOriginalMessage:Sent:Jul23,202006:21From:JonathanGoldbergSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)HiWaiTheservicecatalogdefinitionreflectstheservice,nottheoperationsthatyoucarryoutontheservice.YoushouldcreateasingleVoiceMailservicespecificationinthecatalog.Toadd,change,orremovevoice-mail,youwouldpresumablyneedtoprocessaserviceorderTMF641-orperhapsifyoucanworkdirectlyagainstthenetworkyoucoulduseserviceactivationandconfigurationTMF640.Specificcommentsonyourproposedmodel:TheOpenAPImodeldoesnotdistinguishbetweenCFSandRFS-ifyouwanttomakethatdistinctionthat'sfine,butthenyouneedtoincludea@baseTypethatcontainsServiceSpecificationanda@schemaLocationthatdefinesCFSextensiontoServiceSpec.Ithinkitwouldbebettertohavetruevaluesinyourcharacteristicexamples,sothatsomeonewholooksatthespec(andtheinstantiationintheinventory)canunderstandthesemanticmeaning.Valuessuchas"3"and"5"forserviceclass,or"1"and"2"fornationallanguage,arenotnecessarilyhelpful.IfyousetisBundletotrue,theexpectationisthattheservicespechassub-structure,andIwouldexpecttoseeareferencetoacontainedservicespec.Hopeithelps------------------------------JonathanGoldbergAmdocsManagementLimitedAnyopinionsandstatementsmadebymeonthisforumarepurelypersonal,anddonotnecessarilyreflectthepositionoftheTMForumormyemployer.OriginalMessage:Sent:Jul23,202004:15From:waichowSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)HiJonathan,Thanksforyourclarification.IfIneedtocreatewiththreeoperations/actions,shouldIcreate1servicecatalog3servicecatalog(,,)?eg/{ "name": "ADDVMS", "description": "Add Voice Mail Service Specification", "isBundle": true, "lastUpdate": "2020-07-22T02:47:10.141Z", "lifecycleStatus": "Active", "version": "0.1", "serviceSpecCharacteristic": [ { "configurable": true, "name": "MSISDN", "description": "Mobile Number", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "valueType": "string" }, { "configurable": true, "name": "IMSI", "description": "IMSINumber", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "valueType": "string" }, { "configurable": true, "name": "BRANDCODE", "description": "Brand (mapping)", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "valueType": "string", "serviceSpecCharacteristicValue": [ { "isDefault": true, "valueType": "String" "value": "0" }, { "isDefault": false, "valueType": "String" "value": "1" } ] }, { "configurable": true, "name": "VMSSERVICECLASS", "description": "Mail Box Type", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "regex": "", "valueType": "string", "serviceSpecCharacteristicValue": [ { "isDefault": true, "valueType": "String" "value": "3" }, { "isDefault": false, "valueType": "String" "value": "5" } ] }, { "configurable": true, "name": "VMSLANG", "description": "Mail Box Language (mapping)", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "regex": "", "valueType": "string", "serviceSpecCharacteristicValue": [ { "isDefault": false, "valueType": "String" "value": "1" }, { "isDefault": true, "valueType": "String" "value": "2" }, { "isDefault": false, "valueType": "String" "value": "3" } ] } ], "@type": "CustomerFacingServiceSpecification"}Thanks------------------------------waichowPCCWSolutionsLimitedOriginalMessage:Sent:Jul21,202008:19From:JonathanGoldbergSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)HiWaiWelcome,hopeyouwillfindyourinteractionwiththeTMForumproductiveforyourselfandyourcompany.AllthepublishedOpenAPIuserguides(weusedtocallthemspecifications)includeexamplesofJSONresourcesandpayloads.AstheOpenAPIteamcontinuetoworkonAPIdefinitions,wetrytorefineandupdatetheexamplessothattheywillreflectrealbusinessscenarios,asfaraspossible.Indeedthesimplestwaytodefineaserviceinthecatalogistousecompletelydynamicdefinitions,withspecifications,specificationcharacteristics,andvalues.Anexamplebelow(admittedlyfromResourceCatalog,buttheideaisverysimilarforServiceCatalog)foraverysimplespecforastoragewithonecharacteristicforthemaximumstorage,usingvaluestorepresentthelistofallowedvalues.Hopeithelps.{ "name":"VirtualStorageMedium", "description":"Thisresourcespecificationdefinesthevirtualstoragemedium", "@type":"LogicalResourceSpecification", "@baseType":"ResourceSpecification", "resourceSpecCharacteristic":[ { "name":"MaximumAllowedStorage", "description":"Thestoragelimitinthevirtualstoragemedium,", "valueType":"integer", "configurable":true, "minCardinality":1, "maxCardinality":1, "isUnique":true, "resourceSpecCharacteristicValue":[ { "valueType":"integer", "value":1024000 }, { "valueType":"integer", "value":2048000 } ] } ]}------------------------------JonathanGoldbergAmdocsManagementLimitedAnyopinionsandstatementsmadebymeonthisforumarepurelypersonal,anddonotnecessarilyreflectthepositionoftheTMForumormyemployer.OriginalMessage:Sent:Jul21,202002:48From:waichowSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)Hi,I'mnewtoTMForumandevaluatehowtorevampinhouseSOMapplicationbasedonTMF633/TMF641/TMF638.IreadTMF633ServicecatalogmanagementAPIRESTspecification(release18.5.0/pp21,27-29)butIhavenogluehowtodeclare/representsimple(keyvalue)servicespecification.Forsimple/standaloneservicespecwithoutanyservicedependency,shouldIdeclareeverythinginServiceSpecification/ServiceSpecCharacteristic/ServiceSpecCharacteristicValue?Regards------------------------------WaiChowPCCWSolutionsLimited------------------------------
10.
RE:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)
0
Like
TMForumMember
WingSin
PostedAug25,202007:57
Reply
ReplyPrivately
OptionsDropdown
Hi Jonathan,Thanksforyourcomments,Ihaveupdatedthespec.Wouldyoupleaseadviseifwecouldincludethesemanticmeaningwith"description"tagaswewanttopassthosevalueinstead.Oristhereanybetterapproach? Thanks.
"serviceSpecCharacteristicValue":[
{
"isDefault":true,
"valueType":"String",
"description":"Normal",
"value":"3"
},
{
"isDefault":false,
"valueType":"String",
"description":"Premium",
"value":"5"
}
]
{
"id":"1",
"name":"VMS",
"description":"VoiceMailServiceSpecification",
"lastUpdate":"2020-07-22T02:47:10.141Z",
"lifecycleStatus":"Active",
"version":"0.1",
"serviceSpecCharacteristic":[
{
"configurable":true,
"name":"MSISDN",
"description":"MobileNumber",
"extensible":true,
"isUnique":true,
"maxCardinality":1,
"minCardinality":1,
"valueType":"string"
},
{
"configurable":true,
"name":"IMSI",
"description":"MobileSIMNumber",
"extensible":true,
"isUnique":true,
"maxCardinality":1,
"minCardinality":1,
"valueType":"string"
},
{
"configurable":true,
"name":"BRANDCODE",
"description":"Brand",
"extensible":true,
"isUnique":true,
"maxCardinality":1,
"minCardinality":1,
"valueType":"string",
"serviceSpecCharacteristicValue":[
{
"isDefault":true,
"valueType":"String",
"value":"0"
},
{
"isDefault":false,
"valueType":"String",
"value":"1"
}
]
},
{
"configurable":true,
"name":"VMSSERVICECLASS",
"description":"MailBoxType",
"extensible":true,
"isUnique":true,
"maxCardinality":1,
"minCardinality":1,
"regex":"",
"valueType":"string",
"serviceSpecCharacteristicValue":[
{
"isDefault":true,
"valueType":"String",
"value":"3"
},
{
"isDefault":false,
"valueType":"String",
"value":"5"
}
]
},
{
"configurable":true,
"name":"VMSLANG",
"description":"MailBoxLanguage",
"extensible":true,
"isUnique":true,
"maxCardinality":1,
"minCardinality":1,
"regex":"",
"valueType":"string",
"serviceSpecCharacteristicValue":[
{
"isDefault":false,
"valueType":"String",
"value":"1"
},
{
"isDefault":true,
"valueType":"String",
"value":"2"
},
{
"isDefault":false,
"valueType":"String",
"value":"3"
}
]
}
]
}----------------------------------------------------------------WingSinPCCWSolutionsLimited----------------------------------------------------------------
OriginalMessage
OriginalMessage:Sent:Jul23,202006:21From:JonathanGoldbergSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)HiWaiTheservicecatalogdefinitionreflectstheservice,nottheoperationsthatyoucarryoutontheservice.YoushouldcreateasingleVoiceMailservicespecificationinthecatalog.Toadd,change,orremovevoice-mail,youwouldpresumablyneedtoprocessaserviceorderTMF641-orperhapsifyoucanworkdirectlyagainstthenetworkyoucoulduseserviceactivationandconfigurationTMF640.Specificcommentsonyourproposedmodel:TheOpenAPImodeldoesnotdistinguishbetweenCFSandRFS-ifyouwanttomakethatdistinctionthat'sfine,butthenyouneedtoincludea@baseTypethatcontainsServiceSpecificationanda@schemaLocationthatdefinesCFSextensiontoServiceSpec.Ithinkitwouldbebettertohavetruevaluesinyourcharacteristicexamples,sothatsomeonewholooksatthespec(andtheinstantiationintheinventory)canunderstandthesemanticmeaning.Valuessuchas"3"and"5"forserviceclass,or"1"and"2"fornationallanguage,arenotnecessarilyhelpful.IfyousetisBundletotrue,theexpectationisthattheservicespechassub-structure,andIwouldexpecttoseeareferencetoacontainedservicespec.Hopeithelps------------------------------JonathanGoldbergAmdocsManagementLimitedAnyopinionsandstatementsmadebymeonthisforumarepurelypersonal,anddonotnecessarilyreflectthepositionoftheTMForumormyemployer.OriginalMessage:Sent:Jul23,202004:15From:waichowSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)HiJonathan,Thanksforyourclarification.IfIneedtocreatewiththreeoperations/actions,shouldIcreate1servicecatalog3servicecatalog(,,)?eg/{ "name": "ADDVMS", "description": "Add Voice Mail Service Specification", "isBundle": true, "lastUpdate": "2020-07-22T02:47:10.141Z", "lifecycleStatus": "Active", "version": "0.1", "serviceSpecCharacteristic": [ { "configurable": true, "name": "MSISDN", "description": "Mobile Number", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "valueType": "string" }, { "configurable": true, "name": "IMSI", "description": "IMSINumber", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "valueType": "string" }, { "configurable": true, "name": "BRANDCODE", "description": "Brand (mapping)", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "valueType": "string", "serviceSpecCharacteristicValue": [ { "isDefault": true, "valueType": "String" "value": "0" }, { "isDefault": false, "valueType": "String" "value": "1" } ] }, { "configurable": true, "name": "VMSSERVICECLASS", "description": "Mail Box Type", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "regex": "", "valueType": "string", "serviceSpecCharacteristicValue": [ { "isDefault": true, "valueType": "String" "value": "3" }, { "isDefault": false, "valueType": "String" "value": "5" } ] }, { "configurable": true, "name": "VMSLANG", "description": "Mail Box Language (mapping)", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "regex": "", "valueType": "string", "serviceSpecCharacteristicValue": [ { "isDefault": false, "valueType": "String" "value": "1" }, { "isDefault": true, "valueType": "String" "value": "2" }, { "isDefault": false, "valueType": "String" "value": "3" } ] } ], "@type": "CustomerFacingServiceSpecification"}Thanks------------------------------waichowPCCWSolutionsLimitedOriginalMessage:Sent:Jul21,202008:19From:JonathanGoldbergSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)HiWaiWelcome,hopeyouwillfindyourinteractionwiththeTMForumproductiveforyourselfandyourcompany.AllthepublishedOpenAPIuserguides(weusedtocallthemspecifications)includeexamplesofJSONresourcesandpayloads.AstheOpenAPIteamcontinuetoworkonAPIdefinitions,wetrytorefineandupdatetheexamplessothattheywillreflectrealbusinessscenarios,asfaraspossible.Indeedthesimplestwaytodefineaserviceinthecatalogistousecompletelydynamicdefinitions,withspecifications,specificationcharacteristics,andvalues.Anexamplebelow(admittedlyfromResourceCatalog,buttheideaisverysimilarforServiceCatalog)foraverysimplespecforastoragewithonecharacteristicforthemaximumstorage,usingvaluestorepresentthelistofallowedvalues.Hopeithelps.{ "name":"VirtualStorageMedium", "description":"Thisresourcespecificationdefinesthevirtualstoragemedium", "@type":"LogicalResourceSpecification", "@baseType":"ResourceSpecification", "resourceSpecCharacteristic":[ { "name":"MaximumAllowedStorage", "description":"Thestoragelimitinthevirtualstoragemedium,", "valueType":"integer", "configurable":true, "minCardinality":1, "maxCardinality":1, "isUnique":true, "resourceSpecCharacteristicValue":[ { "valueType":"integer", "value":1024000 }, { "valueType":"integer", "value":2048000 } ] } ]}------------------------------JonathanGoldbergAmdocsManagementLimitedAnyopinionsandstatementsmadebymeonthisforumarepurelypersonal,anddonotnecessarilyreflectthepositionoftheTMForumormyemployer.OriginalMessage:Sent:Jul21,202002:48From:waichowSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)Hi,I'mnewtoTMForumandevaluatehowtorevampinhouseSOMapplicationbasedonTMF633/TMF641/TMF638.IreadTMF633ServicecatalogmanagementAPIRESTspecification(release18.5.0/pp21,27-29)butIhavenogluehowtodeclare/representsimple(keyvalue)servicespecification.Forsimple/standaloneservicespecwithoutanyservicedependency,shouldIdeclareeverythinginServiceSpecification/ServiceSpecCharacteristic/ServiceSpecCharacteristicValue?Regards------------------------------WaiChowPCCWSolutionsLimited------------------------------
11.
RE:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)
0
Like
TMForumMember
JonathanGoldberg
PostedAug26,202001:46
Reply
ReplyPrivately
OptionsDropdown
HiWingTomynon-practicedeyeyourexamplelooksOK.Ialreadystatedmyrecommendation,whichisthatifyouareinanycaseextendingCharacteristicValueSpecificationthen"displayValue"seemstomeabetternamethan"description".Hopeithelps------------------------------JonathanGoldbergAmdocsManagementLimitedAnyopinionsandstatementsmadebymeonthisforumarepurelypersonal,anddonotnecessarilyreflectthepositionoftheTMForumormyemployer.------------------------------
OriginalMessage
OriginalMessage:Sent:Jul27,202002:22From:WingSinSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)Hi Jonathan,Thanksforyourcomments,Ihaveupdatedthespec.Wouldyoupleaseadviseifwecouldincludethesemanticmeaningwith"description"tagaswewanttopassthosevalueinstead.Oristhereanybetterapproach? Thanks."serviceSpecCharacteristicValue":[{"isDefault":true,"valueType":"String","description":"Normal","value":"3"},{"isDefault":false,"valueType":"String","description":"Premium","value":"5"}]{"id":"1","name":"VMS","description":"VoiceMailServiceSpecification","lastUpdate":"2020-07-22T02:47:10.141Z","lifecycleStatus":"Active","version":"0.1","serviceSpecCharacteristic":[{"configurable":true,"name":"MSISDN","description":"MobileNumber","extensible":true,"isUnique":true,"maxCardinality":1,"minCardinality":1,"valueType":"string"},{"configurable":true,"name":"IMSI","description":"MobileSIMNumber","extensible":true,"isUnique":true,"maxCardinality":1,"minCardinality":1,"valueType":"string"},{"configurable":true,"name":"BRANDCODE","description":"Brand","extensible":true,"isUnique":true,"maxCardinality":1,"minCardinality":1,"valueType":"string","serviceSpecCharacteristicValue":[{"isDefault":true, "valueType":"String","value":"0"},{"isDefault":false, "valueType":"String","value":"1"}]},{"configurable":true,"name":"VMSSERVICECLASS","description":"MailBoxType","extensible":true,"isUnique":true,"maxCardinality":1,"minCardinality":1,"regex":"","valueType":"string","serviceSpecCharacteristicValue":[{"isDefault":true, "valueType":"String","value":"3"},{"isDefault":false, "valueType":"String","value":"5"}]},{"configurable":true,"name":"VMSLANG","description":"MailBoxLanguage","extensible":true,"isUnique":true,"maxCardinality":1,"minCardinality":1,"regex":"","valueType":"string","serviceSpecCharacteristicValue":[{"isDefault":false, "valueType":"String","value":"1"},{"isDefault":true, "valueType":"String","value":"2"},{"isDefault":false, "valueType":"String","value":"3"}]}]}----------------------------------------------------------------WingSinPCCWSolutionsLimited----------------------------------OriginalMessage:Sent:Jul23,202006:21From:JonathanGoldbergSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)HiWaiTheservicecatalogdefinitionreflectstheservice,nottheoperationsthatyoucarryoutontheservice.YoushouldcreateasingleVoiceMailservicespecificationinthecatalog.Toadd,change,orremovevoice-mail,youwouldpresumablyneedtoprocessaserviceorderTMF641-orperhapsifyoucanworkdirectlyagainstthenetworkyoucoulduseserviceactivationandconfigurationTMF640.Specificcommentsonyourproposedmodel:TheOpenAPImodeldoesnotdistinguishbetweenCFSandRFS-ifyouwanttomakethatdistinctionthat'sfine,butthenyouneedtoincludea@baseTypethatcontainsServiceSpecificationanda@schemaLocationthatdefinesCFSextensiontoServiceSpec.Ithinkitwouldbebettertohavetruevaluesinyourcharacteristicexamples,sothatsomeonewholooksatthespec(andtheinstantiationintheinventory)canunderstandthesemanticmeaning.Valuessuchas"3"and"5"forserviceclass,or"1"and"2"fornationallanguage,arenotnecessarilyhelpful.IfyousetisBundletotrue,theexpectationisthattheservicespechassub-structure,andIwouldexpecttoseeareferencetoacontainedservicespec.Hopeithelps------------------------------JonathanGoldbergAmdocsManagementLimitedAnyopinionsandstatementsmadebymeonthisforumarepurelypersonal,anddonotnecessarilyreflectthepositionoftheTMForumormyemployer.OriginalMessage:Sent:Jul23,202004:15From:waichowSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)HiJonathan,Thanksforyourclarification.IfIneedtocreatewiththreeoperations/actions,shouldIcreate1servicecatalog3servicecatalog(,,)?eg/{ "name": "ADDVMS", "description": "Add Voice Mail Service Specification", "isBundle": true, "lastUpdate": "2020-07-22T02:47:10.141Z", "lifecycleStatus": "Active", "version": "0.1", "serviceSpecCharacteristic": [ { "configurable": true, "name": "MSISDN", "description": "Mobile Number", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "valueType": "string" }, { "configurable": true, "name": "IMSI", "description": "IMSINumber", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "valueType": "string" }, { "configurable": true, "name": "BRANDCODE", "description": "Brand (mapping)", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "valueType": "string", "serviceSpecCharacteristicValue": [ { "isDefault": true, "valueType": "String" "value": "0" }, { "isDefault": false, "valueType": "String" "value": "1" } ] }, { "configurable": true, "name": "VMSSERVICECLASS", "description": "Mail Box Type", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "regex": "", "valueType": "string", "serviceSpecCharacteristicValue": [ { "isDefault": true, "valueType": "String" "value": "3" }, { "isDefault": false, "valueType": "String" "value": "5" } ] }, { "configurable": true, "name": "VMSLANG", "description": "Mail Box Language (mapping)", "extensible": true, "isUnique": true, "maxCardinality": 1, "minCardinality": 1, "regex": "", "valueType": "string", "serviceSpecCharacteristicValue": [ { "isDefault": false, "valueType": "String" "value": "1" }, { "isDefault": true, "valueType": "String" "value": "2" }, { "isDefault": false, "valueType": "String" "value": "3" } ] } ], "@type": "CustomerFacingServiceSpecification"}Thanks------------------------------waichowPCCWSolutionsLimitedOriginalMessage:Sent:Jul21,202008:19From:JonathanGoldbergSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)HiWaiWelcome,hopeyouwillfindyourinteractionwiththeTMForumproductiveforyourselfandyourcompany.AllthepublishedOpenAPIuserguides(weusedtocallthemspecifications)includeexamplesofJSONresourcesandpayloads.AstheOpenAPIteamcontinuetoworkonAPIdefinitions,wetrytorefineandupdatetheexamplessothattheywillreflectrealbusinessscenarios,asfaraspossible.Indeedthesimplestwaytodefineaserviceinthecatalogistousecompletelydynamicdefinitions,withspecifications,specificationcharacteristics,andvalues.Anexamplebelow(admittedlyfromResourceCatalog,buttheideaisverysimilarforServiceCatalog)foraverysimplespecforastoragewithonecharacteristicforthemaximumstorage,usingvaluestorepresentthelistofallowedvalues.Hopeithelps.{ "name":"VirtualStorageMedium", "description":"Thisresourcespecificationdefinesthevirtualstoragemedium", "@type":"LogicalResourceSpecification", "@baseType":"ResourceSpecification", "resourceSpecCharacteristic":[ { "name":"MaximumAllowedStorage", "description":"Thestoragelimitinthevirtualstoragemedium,", "valueType":"integer", "configurable":true, "minCardinality":1, "maxCardinality":1, "isUnique":true, "resourceSpecCharacteristicValue":[ { "valueType":"integer", "value":1024000 }, { "valueType":"integer", "value":2048000 } ] } ]}------------------------------JonathanGoldbergAmdocsManagementLimitedAnyopinionsandstatementsmadebymeonthisforumarepurelypersonal,anddonotnecessarilyreflectthepositionoftheTMForumormyemployer.OriginalMessage:Sent:Jul21,202002:48From:waichowSubject:UnderstandingTMF633(howtodeclaresimpleservicespecification)Hi,I'mnewtoTMForumandevaluatehowtorevampinhouseSOMapplicationbasedonTMF633/TMF641/TMF638.IreadTMF633ServicecatalogmanagementAPIRESTspecification(release18.5.0/pp21,27-29)butIhavenogluehowtodeclare/representsimple(keyvalue)servicespecification.Forsimple/standaloneservicespecwithoutanyservicedependency,shouldIdeclareeverythinginServiceSpecification/ServiceSpecCharacteristic/ServiceSpecCharacteristicValue?Regards------------------------------WaiChowPCCWSolutionsLimited------------------------------
×
NewBestAnswer
Thisthreadalreadyhasabestanswer.Wouldyouliketomarkthismessageasthenewbestanswer?
No
Copyright2019TMForum.Allrightsreserved.ViewourWebsiteT&CsandPrivacyPolicy.
PoweredbyHigherLogic
